PosiStep 17: Red flags, fraud and governance
Most losses from frauds and collapses showed warning signs beforehand. This PosiStep lists the common red flags and what good corporate governance (how honestly and carefully a company is run) looks like.
Regulatory and legal actions
Orders from SEBI, the exchanges, the SEC or courts, such as penalties, trading bans, investigations or insolvency proceedings, are among the most serious signs. They show that a regulator or court found something wrong, or is looking.
Auditor problems
The auditor checks a company's accounts. Warning signs include an auditor resigning mid-term, a qualified opinion (the auditor disagrees with part of the accounts), frequent changes of auditor, or a very small auditor for a large company.
Money moving to insiders
Related-party transactions are deals between the company and its promoters, directors or their other businesses: loans, rent, purchases. They are legal when fair and disclosed, but large or unusual ones can move money from shareholders to insiders.
High promoter pledging (PosiStep 10) and promoters steadily selling their shares are also worth attention.
Numbers that don't add up
Profits that rise year after year while operating cash flow stays weak or negative (PosiStep 13); customers' unpaid bills (receivables) growing much faster than sales; frequent changes in accounting; or growth far faster than any competitor without a clear reason.
Delayed results or filings, and sudden exits of the CEO or finance head (CFO), add to the concern.
Good governance looks like
Timely, clear disclosures; independent directors who are truly independent; a reputable auditor; fair treatment of minority shareholders; profits backed by cash; and management that explains bad news openly. No company is perfect, but the pattern matters.
Where PositoAI fits
PosiFlag shows red flags (serious regulatory and legal actions) and yellow flags (stress signals such as high pledging or financial strain) for each company, with details and dates. Red flags lower the Positivity Score. The no red flags and no red or yellow flags Top 10 lists show companies without them.
Key terms
- Corporate governance
- How honestly, fairly and carefully a company is run and supervised.
- Qualified opinion
- An auditor's statement that part of the accounts may not be right.
- Related-party transaction
- A deal between the company and its insiders or their businesses.
- Red flag (PosiFlag)
- A serious regulatory or legal warning sign shown by PositoAI.
- Yellow flag (PosiFlag)
- A stress signal, such as high pledging, shown by PositoAI.
- Independent director
- A board member with no ties to management, meant to protect shareholders.
Try it
Made-up company Quartz Infra reports: profit up for 5 years in a row; operating cash flow negative in 4 of those 5 years; its auditor resigned mid-year; promoters pledged 70% of their shares. How many of these are warning signs?
Rising profit alone is not a warning. But profit without cash for years, an auditor resigning mid-year, and 70% pledging are three separate red flags.
See it live on PositoAI
Open the PosiFlag page and read what counts as a red flag and a yellow flag. Then open the no red or yellow flags Top 10 list for India.
What this does not tell you
No checklist catches every fraud, and some flags turn out to be harmless. A company without flags can still disappoint. Flags are reasons to look deeper, not verdicts.
Quick quiz
Which is a serious warning sign?
A mid-term auditor resignation can mean disagreements over the accounts; the others are normal or positive.
What is a related-party transaction?
Deals with promoters, directors or their businesses are related-party transactions; large ones deserve scrutiny.
Profit rises every year but operating cash flow stays negative. This may mean:
Profits without matching cash for years can signal aggressive accounting or customers not paying.
In PositoAI's PosiFlag, a red flag means:
Red flags are serious regulatory and legal actions; yellow flags are stress signals such as high pledging.
Which is a sign of good governance?
Good governance means open, timely reporting and independent checks; the others are warning signs.
Answer every question on this page correctly to complete this PosiStep.
🏅
PosiCourse is for education only. It does not recommend buying or selling any share. Examples with made-up numbers are not real companies. PositoAI is for research and education only and is not investment advice.